Imagine this: you launch your startup. You succeeded at fundraising and business development. One of your early investors seeks to transfer their stock holdings. Great, right? Maybe. However, the shares could be sold to someone who does not support your company vision. Or worse, to a competitor?
Worried? Well, the Right of First Refusal clause known as ROFR provides you that protection.
The concept might seem unimpressive at its onset. However, this clause safeguards your startup by preventing dozens of potential complications. Startup investors should learn about the Right of First Refusal clause to better understand how startup deals operate. Let’s break it down to understand the Right of First Refusal clause meaning with a Right of First Refusal clause sample and a Right of First Refusal clause example.
What Is the Right of First Refusal Clause? (aka ROFR)
A Right of First Refusal clause provides specified parties the chance to match outside offers before finalizing any transaction with a third party. In the startup world, the company together with its existing investors has priority access to acquire shares before external buyers obtain them.
Right of First Refusal Clause Meaning
Simply put, the Right of First Refusal Clause means the primary buying right belongs to the designated party before an asset is transferred to other parties. Before you sell your property to anyone else, the internal shareholders have the exclusive right to acquire it at the same conditions that you offer.
This clause is common in:
- Shareholder agreements
- Founders' stock agreements
- Investor rights agreements
- Real estate lease agreements
The startup world operates mainly through equity exchanges for ownership control. The clause provides existing shareholders or the organization with protection against unwanted external acquisition attempts.
Why Is the ROFR Clause Important?
Startups are delicate ecosystems. A single inappropriate player within the startup ecosystem has the potential to harm its aesthetic feel and affect its financial evaluation. So, here’s why the ROFR clause matters:
1. Protects Founders and the Cap Table
If a founder wants to sell part of their shares, then this clause becomes relevant. Without such a clause, the founder might sell shares to anyone including a possible competitor.
When ROFR exists, the company along with its investors possesses the right to acquire those shares from the seller.
2. Keeps the Circle Tight
The Founders along with early-stage investors actively maintain control over which participants receive positions as shareholders. When ROFR protects ownership interests, it supports the control of assets within the investor group.
3. Aligns Long-Term Interests
A ROFR mechanism makes stockholders reluctant to dispose of their holdings. The startup’s journey becomes more stable due to this provision.
Right of First Refusal Clause Example
Let’s examine a short real-life right of first refusal clause example in operation.
You are Sarah, the founder of PetNet. You launched PetNet, a technology-powered system for pet adoptions.
Early on, you granted Jake a stake amount of 10% ownership in the company. Jake has decided to sell his shares from the initial equity stake three years after receiving them. The third external party which makes an offer is FurCo, a well-known pet food giant.
Your business will fall apart if FurCo makes an attempt to join. Your concerns stem from their ability to make decisions which could potentially force a merger against your established vision.
Your shareholder agreement includes the ROFR clause that gives PetNet the exclusive right to that purchase offer. You possess 30 days to execute a share purchase at FurCo's current price point to acquire Jake's portion of ownership.
That’s how ROFR helps in crisis aversion.
How Does It Work?
Shareholders who want to sell their shares normally initiate the ROFR process. The step-by-step sequence for ROFR implementation is here:
- Notification: The selling shareholder reveals a validated third-party purchase offer to either the company or ROFR holder.
- Time to Decide: The party exercising rights of first refusal receives a specific period between 15 to 30 days to respond either by accepting or rejecting the bid.
- Matching the Offer: The ROFR holder must match the entire terms, including price and other factors, provided by the third-party in a purchase decision.
- Transaction Closes: When an ROFR gets exercised, the transaction will proceed as a direct purchase by the ROFR holder. The seller maintains freedom to pursue a third-party transaction, if an ROFR agreement is not accepted.
Right of First Refusal Clause Sample
A practical demonstration of this concept appears in actual contracts. Here’s a basic right of first refusal clause sample:
1. Right of First Refusal
In the event that any shareholder of BrightSpark Technologies Pvt. Ltd. (the "Selling Shareholder") proposes to sell, transfer, assign, or otherwise dispose of all or any part of their shares in the Company (the "Offered Shares") to any third party, the Selling Shareholder shall first offer such Offered Shares to the other existing shareholders of the Company (the "Remaining Shareholders") on the same terms and conditions as those offered to the third party.
2. Notice of Offer
The Selling Shareholder shall deliver a written notice (the "Offer Notice") to the Remaining Shareholders specifying:
(a) the number of Offered Shares,
(b) the purchase price,
(c) the identity of the proposed third-party purchaser, and
(d) all other material terms and conditions of the proposed transfer.
3. Exercise of Right
The Remaining Shareholders shall have 30 (thirty) days from the date of receipt of the Offer Notice to notify the Selling Shareholder in writing of their election to purchase all (but not less than all) of the Offered Shares on the terms set forth in the Offer Notice. If multiple Remaining Shareholders elect to exercise this right, the Offered Shares shall be allocated among them on a pro-rata basis according to their existing shareholdings in the Company, unless they agree otherwise in writing.
4. Failure to Exercise
If the Remaining Shareholders do not exercise their right of first refusal within the specified 30-day period, the Selling Shareholder shall have the right, for a period of 90 (ninety) days thereafter, to sell the Offered Shares to the proposed third-party purchaser on terms no more favorable than those offered in the Offer Notice. If the sale to the third party is not completed within this 90-day period, any subsequent proposed transfer shall again be subject to the terms of this Right of First Refusal clause.
5. Assignment.
This Right of First Refusal shall be binding upon and insure to the benefit of the shareholders of BrightSpark Technologies Pvt. Ltd., and their respective successors and permitted assigns.
Pros and Cons of a ROFR Clause
The Right of First Refusal clause appears strong at first glance. However, it does have a few disadvantages. Before entering into agreements, everyone involved should understand the benefits and risks attached to it.
Pros of ROFR
- Protects Control & Vision
The Right of First Refusal protects the mission by letting only compatible trusted parties purchase stock in the company. - Prevents Unwanted Transfers
Key shareholders and founders will always learn about proposed share deals in advance. The offering of shares must begin within the organization before moving outside. - Encourages Long-Term Thinking
With limited liquidity, it leads the shareholders to stay committed to the company both financially and emotionally. - Maintains a Cleaner Cap Table
Few random shareholders simplify decision making processes and reduce ownership confusion that yields better funding paths.
Cons of ROFR
- Can Delay Transactions
Share sales are paused during the ROFR evaluation period that normally lasts between 15 and 30 days. This causes transactional delays. - May Discourage External Buyers
Third-party buyers will probably skip bidding as there is a possibility of their offer being matched. - Becomes Complex at Scale
When there are numerous shareholders, the management process of tracking notices, meeting deadlines, and responding becomes a logistical challenge. - Risk of Internal Power Struggles
ROFR allows political manipulation to block deals while concentrating control among specific shareholders. It might lead to possible organizational tensions at times.
Who Usually Gets ROFR Rights?
The Right of First Refusal privilege belongs only to particular members in attendance. Here are the ones who get it:
Founders and the Company
A majority of startups grant their Right of First Refusal to the company, allowing it to buy shares before external buyers approach. Founders normally add this provision to sustain their control position and prevent unexpected events. Moreover, they establish personal ROFR rights in addition to the company-owned rights to defend against shareholder dilution.
Investors (Especially VCs)
VCs love ROFRs. It protects their ownership position and keeps their influence intact along with keeping the cap table clean. ROFR appears as a regular component in the majority of VC term sheets.
Employees and Advisors
ROFRs do not belong to employees or advisors, but these groups must obey the ROFR requirements. To sell their vested shares, company investors or shareholders must be given an opportunity to purchase the stocks first.
Tiers of ROFR
Sometimes, ROFR rights come in layers:
- The company gets the first shot.
- Then major investors.
- Then minority shareholders.
The "waterfall" structure allows control to move steadily towards the employees who strongly care about business success. However, the process gets complicated when different parties seek participation and their time frames overlap.
Final Thoughts
We hope that you now understand how the Right of First Refusal clause meaning works after looking at the Right of First Refusal clause sample and the Right of First Refusal clause example.
To sum up, Right of First Refusal stands as a key component in startup life. It works quietly to prevent and enable major changes for your startup. Through this clause, you gain authority to halt any decision.
Knowledge about this specific clause enables founders to protect their capital structures, investors to defend their power, and employees to plan their departures better.
Want to Learn More?
Angel School’s Venture Fundamentals course teaches about complicated startup legal documentation through simplified explanations. No legalese. No fluff. Just real knowledge from real investors.
If you are looking to invest in a startup or run a startup business, you should join. This course might be the founding stone of your investment journey. Keep learning!
About AngelSchool.vc
AngelSchool.vc is the ultimate Accelerator for Angel Investors - from 1st check to leading syndicates as ‘Super Angels’. We give venture investors world-class training, a global community AND build their track record as a member of our Investment Committee (IC).
The AngelSchool.vc Syndicate is backed by 1400+ LPs and deploys $MNs annually. Subscribe here for exclusive dealflow.
